August 31 2006 • 10:44 PM

Getting Rid of Text Size Parentheses

Jesi wrote:

I design a lot of ads, which will be used in multiple publications. When I copy and paste the entire ad into a different template and resize, the type size that is shown in the Character window stays the same, but the “actual” type size shows up behind it in parentheses. This is very frustrating as I’d like to see at a glance what my actual type size is.

Jesi, this is a huge problem for many people. The problem typically appears when you scale one or more text frames in a group. For example, these two text frames were grouped and then enlarged:

TextScaleProblem1

Notice how the selected text’s point size appears as both 12 point and 27.86 point (in parentheses, sometimes called brackets). The 12 point is the original text size and the number in parens is the size after scaling.

So what do you do about it? You must choose Object > Ungroup and then choose Scale Text Attributes from the Control palette flyout menu. This feature only appears when you have a scaled text frame like this.

TextScaleProblem2

No one disputes that this is painful and unpleasant (even engineers at Adobe have quietly agreed with me on this point), but it’s the only good solution for now.

34 Responses discussing this post. Add yours below.

  1. September 3rd, 2006 • 4:13 pm • Link

    While we’re on the subject of text peeves — how come the shift-delete shortcut to delete the next character keeps coming and going? It was there in CS; now it’s gone again in CS2. Maybe it could come back in the next update? And stay forever?

  2. September 3rd, 2006 • 8:00 pm • Link

    Just use the Delete key to delete the next character. The Back Space key will delete the previous character.

    Are you working on a portable computer ?

  3. woz
    September 4th, 2006 • 11:17 am • Link

    I can’t see what the point of knowing the origional size is. For god’s sake Adobe, drop us an update here! (While you’re at it, fix the max. caracter of file names when exporting pdf as well)

  4. September 4th, 2006 • 11:46 am • Link

    They thought it could be useful to know it !

    Adobe should really put an end to the 31 character limit in file’s name.

  5. September 4th, 2006 • 1:22 pm • Link

    Believe it or not, there are many people who really like the “before/after” text sizes because they enjoy knowing they can return to the original size at any time. That’s why Adobe offers the “Adjust Text Attributes When Scaling” checkbox in the Type panel of the Preferences dialog box. When that feature is off you’ll always get those wacky parentheses (until you choose Scale Text Attributes).

  6. September 4th, 2006 • 2:37 pm • Link

    > Believe it or not, there are many
    > people who really like the “before/
    > after” text sizes because they enjoy
    > knowing they can return to the
    > original size at any time.

    Since YouTube you see how much people like to enjoy strange fantasies……… :D

  7. max
    September 27th, 2006 • 9:46 am • Link

    been searching for the solution to this “problem” for a while. sure this can be handy if you want to return to the original size, but its good that i now can disable that if i want! Thanks!!!

  8. fur
    October 15th, 2006 • 12:41 pm • Link

    I can’t ungroup my text box because it is not part of a group. It is justa scaled box. What now? I can’t find Scale Text Attributes at all

  9. David Blatner
    October 15th, 2006 • 1:04 pm • Link

    Fur, see my comment above about the ““Adjust Text Attributes When Scaling” checkbox. Perhaps that is turned on? If not, I wonder if something is corrupted or messed up. Try grouping it with something and then ungrouping it again; try exporting the object as a snippet and placing it again?

  10. Joe
    October 27th, 2006 • 4:33 pm • Link

    Hey gang, its a little late but I just stumbled across the same problem with text in a table. Like fur, there was nothing to ungroup and I could not get my text to the correct size although I unchecked the box as David suggested. It turns out the box containing the table was distorted, the scale of the X and Y Percentages were differerent. Setting them back to 100% corrected the font size.

  11. David Blatner
    October 27th, 2006 • 5:07 pm • Link

    Joe, I hadn’t noticed that before. Yes, if you put a table in a text frame, then paste that text frame into another frame (using Paste Into), and then scale the container frame, the text inside the table gets the parentheses. Blech!

    By the way, I have edited my comment above. Originally it said turning on the “Adjust Text Attributes when Scaling” preference gives you the parens. I meant turning it off. Turning it on makes it work the way most people want (the text size adjusts properly). Thanks to Andy MacBride for pointing out my error.

  12. Andy MacBride
    October 30th, 2006 • 12:46 am • Link

    Thanks for the kudos, David.

    And for the rest of us following David’s directions who are puzzled by a missing “scale text attributes” option, it’s because (insert drum roll…) the tool you’re currently using is probably the text tool rather than the selection tool. The flyout menu looks very different when it’s being accessed with the text tool and the selection tool (try it, you’ll be amazed — all kinds of other options appear). Switch, and suddenly you’ll see that option for killing those parens.

    And for those of you who, like me, want to never see these little buggers again, go to your text prefs and check the box next to “Adjust Text Attributes When Scaling” (and make sure no documents open). Then you’ll never see this mysterious behavior again.

  13. David Blatner
    October 30th, 2006 • 4:02 pm • Link

    That’s a very good point, Andy: All kinds of things change in the Control palette depending on which tool and which situation you’re in. It can be mystifying.

    But one correction: Even with that preference turned on, you’ll still see the parens around text sizes in some situations, as have been pointed out above — notably, scaled frames inside groups or scaled frames that have been nested inside other objects. I know that the good folks at Adobe are painfully aware of the inconsistencies here and I’m sure this is one of those things that will get better in future versions.

  14. Kelli
    January 26th, 2007 • 4:33 pm • Link

    Wow. I love this tip. My entire office was struggling with these crazy parenthesis.

  15. May 9th, 2007 • 2:15 am • Link

    Any insight into how to permanently turn off this “feature” in InDesign CS3? I was trying to apply Andy’s tip but Adobe has taken out the “Adjust Text Attributes when Scaling” preference in the Type Preference area.

  16. David Blatner
    May 9th, 2007 • 4:23 pm • Link

    Danny, in CS2 you don’t need to follow those instructions anymore. (Actually, you do if you open a CS2 document with mislabeled text, but not in new docs.)

    In CS3, the parens very rarely appear, even when scaling groups. If you want the parens (that is, you want to see before and after values), then turn on the Adjust Scaling Percentage checkbox in the Preferences dialog box.

  17. Alannie
    June 18th, 2007 • 4:55 pm • Link

    > You must choose Object > Ungroup
    > and then choose Scale
    Text Attributes
    > from the Control palette flyout menu.

    Just thought I would add this tip for those who like me didn’t realize that the palette across the top is called the “Control” palette: the flyout menu can also be found on the “Transform” palette.

  18. Inept Intern
    October 17th, 2007 • 7:54 pm • Link

    I realize this is an older article but it still put me in the right direction. I’m an intern at my office and they said, “Hey, fix this.” None of the solutions seemed to be helpful until I noticed that the text boxes X and Y percentages weren’t at 100%. After some struggling I found it was as simple as going to the Control Palettes flyout menu and clicking redifine scaling at 100%! Simple stuff. (we are using CS3 and just typing 100% in the X and Y percentage weilded no results.)

  19. Liam
    January 10th, 2008 • 12:58 am • Link

    THANK YOU!

    This issue with InDesign has bugged me for years, but I’d always worked around it. Being a new year and all, I figured I’d find out if there was a solution. And there is.

    Thanks to David for his speedy assistance too.

  20. Chris
    January 17th, 2008 • 1:30 pm • Link

    How is this done on ID CS3?

  21. David Blatner
    January 19th, 2008 • 12:54 am • Link

    I think it works in CS3 the same way as it does in CS2, no?

  22. unreceivedogma
    January 23rd, 2008 • 11:47 pm • Link

    It’s these kinda problems that make me wanna scream “Quark still rules”…at least when it comes to certain very basic type manipulations…

  23. David Blatner
    January 24th, 2008 • 1:45 pm • Link

    Unreceivedogma: Well, I can understand the frustration. But it’s one of those “with increased power comes increased complexity.” Hey, at least it’s getting better with each version. ;)

  24. Eric
    July 8th, 2008 • 1:50 pm • Link
  25. mike
    August 5th, 2008 • 9:17 am • Link

    thanks! been trying to figure this out all day.

  26. susan Hoffman
    August 14th, 2008 • 10:07 am • Link

    I’m still having trouble.

    We are using CS3, the preferences are unchecked, I’m using the arrown tool, I don’t have the ‘Scale Text Attributes’ option, I’ve tried the x/y coordinates, and I still have parens. My preferences are correct. This is a CS2 doc that I’ve opened in CS3.

    What am I missing?

  27. Kerry Applin
    February 11th, 2009 • 10:56 am • Link

    Well, over a year of using CS3 and this problem still persists, though as far as I can find (wasted 2 and a half hours so far) Adobe has made this problem even harder to solve. Personally, I will be re-investigating my Quark options (never thought I would say that). This issue is too costly in terms of time to continue to work around.

    This is a “feature” that never should have been introduced in the first place.

    Grrr

  28. Desmene
    March 9th, 2009 • 2:33 pm • Link

    Oh sweet heavens… thanks for posting the fix to this incredibly puzzling and annoying problem!

  29. BLinDesign
    June 12th, 2009 • 1:46 pm • Link

    Try:
    1) click arrow tool on the type box
    2) Window > object & layout > transform
    3) in the transform window, the little arrow in the upper right corner reveals either “scale text attributes” or “redefine scaling at 100%” (depends on version you’re using).

  30. October 11th, 2009 • 12:28 pm • Link

    indeed thxs alot…
    SAVED me from having to work around it…
    I can surly smile again

  31. walter
    November 20th, 2009 • 5:02 am • Link

    Well – its now Cs4. And none of the above applies – all i can find is a command >window >object&layout >transform and from the menu in the transform palette I can select “clear transformation” wich does nothing. Will this überstupid engineerinvented //$#&•// never end?

  32. Brian McNay
    January 27th, 2010 • 11:37 am • Link

    To correct this problem in CS4 simply select the text box in question and return the scaled size percentage to 100%

    Thank you, I’ll be here all week. Don’t forget to tip your Blatner.

  33. liz
    February 1st, 2010 • 2:11 pm • Link

    Any solutions to a problem of typing in menu fields (such as font name of type size) changes the text within the layout of an indesign cs3 document.

  34. February 26th, 2010 • 9:18 am • Link

    I found the solution for CS4 and CS3.

    Select the text box in question, not the text inside it but simply the text box. Now in the upper right corner of the control pallet (the very top menu), near quick apply, click on the control palette flyout menu and choose redefine scaling as 100%.

Subscribe to the Discussion

Get the ongoing discussion surrounding "Getting Rid of Text Size Parentheses" delivered to you. Click here to subscribe via RSS.

Leave a Reply

You can use limited HTML tags, such as <em></em> for emphasis/italics and <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .

InDesignSecrets reserves the right to edit and/or remove posts and comments.