August 14 2007 • 2:51 PM

What happened to the Shear dialog box, Axis: Angle command?

It’s gone. Disappeared! Vanished!

In previous versons of InDesign you could open the Shear dialog box and choose the Shear Angle (which is the amount of shearing), and then choose under the Axis area an angle for the shearing.

And now it’s gone.

You can only choose a Horizontal or Vertical axis.

InDesign Shear dialog

This is so strange, especially since Illustrator still has the “complete” set of shear controls. Notice the Angle option.
Illustrator Shear dialog box

Why would anyone take this out of InDesign? I know nobody ever uses the Angle Axis, but it is very unlike Adobe to take things out of the program.

Any thoughts?

6 Responses discussing this post. Add yours below.

  1. David Blatner
    August 14th, 2007 • 4:26 pm • Link

    Wow, that is kind of weird. My first guess is that it had something to do with the changes in how InDesign CS3 handles scaling. I know that seems nonintuitive, but they did have to do a lot of low-level work to change scaling and perhaps something had to give. As you pointed out, I don’t know anyone who actually used that feature.

    That said, beware the slippery slope! Who knows, they might take out the Type tool in CS4! ;)

  2. August 14th, 2007 • 4:47 pm • Link

    > That said, beware the slippery slope! Who knows, they might take out the Type tool in CS4!

    Type tool? What’s that?

    I never use the Type tool. ;-) :-)

  3. Brian
    August 14th, 2007 • 4:59 pm • Link

    The hell? I think the effect can at least be achieved using shear and rotate together (which I think is what the axis did anyhow), but that’s still really annoying. I actually do use shear every now and then, so…

  4. Peter
    August 14th, 2007 • 9:55 pm • Link

    Anyone remember when Macromedia took the timeline out of Dreamweaver, they had to put it back in since users kept complaining, even though Macromdia’s internal statistics said virtually nobody had really ever used it?

    But we really need that shear axis angle thing back as soon as possible, though. It would make such a nice “obscure InDesign feature of the week” for the podcast …

  5. Eugene Tyson
    August 15th, 2007 • 8:24 am • Link

    Hey Guys, while experimenting here on this I tried the following. I drew a square. Rotated it 15 degrees, then I alt clicked on the Roate button on the Control Panel and it copied it around into a nice diamond formation after 4 clicks. Nothing to do with this, but nice, I think. It works for each of the control panel items, including flip horizontal and vertical.

  6. January 20th, 2009 • 6:24 am • Link

    Unbelievable! This was a major plus in our layouts.

Subscribe to the Discussion

Get the ongoing discussion surrounding "What happened to the Shear dialog box, Axis: Angle command?" delivered to you. Click here to subscribe via RSS.

Leave a Reply

You can use limited HTML tags, such as <em></em> for emphasis/italics and <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .

InDesignSecrets reserves the right to edit and/or remove posts and comments.