Default Graphics Text Frame Issues

I created an Object Style for a text frame. It’s a single column box with .25″ rounded corners, a 1pt outline and .25″ text inset. I made this style my default text frame style as I planned to place overflow text on the next few pages with the same formatting. When I load my cursor with the overflow text and click on the next page, the box it creates is missing the text inset. When I check the text frame options, the inset is showing as .25″. It doesn’t show a local override on the style for that box so there’s no way to fix it. However, if I change it to Basic (or any other object style) and then back to the one I want, the box is correct. Can someone help me figure out why the style is not placing correctly to begin with? Thank you!